I just finished reading the latest compilation of Jeph Loeb's Superman/Batman work,
Absolute Power.
Wow. Just — wow.
This book isn't for everyone. I would like to think it's something a casual reader could pick up and enjoy, but I just don't believe it. There are too many cameo appearances by minor characters, appearances that won't make much sense unless you've read a small mountain of DC comics, particularly comics from the Silver Age (roughly speaking, the 60s and 70s).
But if you're a Silver Age fan, and especially if you miss alternate timelines and multiple Earths — wow.
This book has a simple premise: a trio of supervillains from the 31st century (Legion fans can guess who) decide that their troubles could all be reversed if they simply went back into the past, abducted the infant Kal El and the orphaned Bruce Wayne, and raised them as super enforcers who would rule the 21st century Earth in the service of their adoptive "parents". But from that simple premise, a wild ride ensues.
With the influence of the Kents and Alfred replaced by a vicious trio that includes a telepath who confounded their brains, Earth's two greatest champions of law and order become tyrants of order over all. As one of the last surviving heroes of what would be the Justice League in a different timeline, Wonder Woman assembles Uncle Sam and the Freedom Fighters (if you don't get the reference, you're kinda proving my point about Silver Age references) to battle Superman and Batman and try to restore the timeline. An accident with a time sphere ensues, and Superman and Batman are blasted into more alternate timelines: the post-Great Disaster world of Kamandi (more stuff from the Silver Age); a Gotham City where Jonah Hex, Cinnamon, Tomahawk, and other western and frontier heroes are modern day law enforcers (yet more Silver Age stuff); an Earth where Darkseid rules, along with the Superman from
Kingdom Come and
The Kingdom (modern age books, but books that were also tributes to the Silver Age, and that paved the way for this book); and an Earth where Thomas and Martha Wayne were never murdered, and thus Batman was never created, and thus his greatest foe was unopposed in his quest to conquer the Earth.
The story reaches its denouement at one of the iconic symbols of the DC Silver Age, the original
Legion clubhouse. And it concludes with a tribute to
the book that arguably closed the Silver Age. And when I read that conclusion, my reaction was: wow. Just -- wow. Prior to this, Jeph Loeb was an author whose name I recognized, and I kinda knew he did good work. After this, he's an author I'll search out on the comic racks.
It's hard to describe who the audience for this book is. It's too full of continuity to really make sense to the casual reader; but it also plays too fast and loose with the continuity to please those Continuity Cops who insist on trying to piece every single story into "one seamless tapestry".
Well, actually, there is sort of a description of the audience for this book. It's a one-word description: me.
Other titles picked up today but mostly unread at this time:
- Superman: That Healing Touch. Latest compilation of the ongoing Superman comics. (Aside for those who have read the book: can it really be Pete Ross? Isn't that just a bit too obvious?)
- Minor Miracles by the late Will Eisner. Mr. Eisner's tales of everyday people in an everyday world are anything but everyday. His comics are more literate and have more humanity than anything you'll find in "serious literature" these days.
- Barnum in Secret Service to the USA. P.T. Barnum and his circus as government agents? I've been trying to decide whether to get this one for months. I found it half off, and took a chance. We'll see. (I love circuses, a taste I got from my late father. One is coming to town tomorrow. Look for photos.)
- The Incredible Hulk: Beauty and the Behemoth. This one I've contemplated for years; and again, the discount box persuaded me. I've been putting it off partly because I knew it ended with the death of Bruce Banner's wife, Betty, and I didn't want to end a book on a downer (even if it is written by the talented Peter David). But in reading recent books, I've learned she got better. (Remember, boys and girls, one of the things that "proves" Marvel comics are superior to DC comics is that at Marvel, dead is dead. For everybody. Well, almost everybody. Well, OK, maybe not everybody, but at least for Captain Marvel and Jean Grey and Gwen Stacey, since their deaths were such momentous events! All right, all right, so they brought back Captain Marvel and Jean Grey; but at Marvel, when it comes to Gwen Stacey — poor, powerless Gwen Stacey, who has appeared to "come back" as a clone and also as her accelerated-age near-identical-twin daughter sired by Spider-Man's worst enemy — dead is dead!)
- Spider-Man: The Savage Land Saga. Another one from the "I'll buy it eventually, and it's half off" pile. Spider-Man journeys to the Savage Land, Marvel's dinosaur-populated equivalent of Conan-Doyle's Lost World. (The major difference between the Lost World and the Savage Land is that the latter gets so many visitors from the outside world that I expect Starbucks to open a store there any day now.)
- The Flash: The Secret of Barry Allen. And speaking of "dead is dead": Barry Allen is the one character I can confidently predict that DC won't bring back any time soon. Unlike other dramatic deaths at DC (Green Lantern and Green Arrow being the biggest examples — and yes, they both came back from the dead in recent years), Barry's death (in another book that arguably ended the Silver Age) actually made sense. It served a dramatic purpose, without violating the integrity of the character. And his successor, Wally West, is liked as much as or more than Barry was, by practically all readers. (Again, the contrast with Kyle "Green Lantern" Rayner and Connor "Green Arrow" Hawke is illuminating: each had their fans, but also lots of detractors.) So Barry's gone for good. But boy, does DC like digging back into his past every chance they get. The cover to this one promises some disturbing news in a letter from Barry.
- Ultimate Spider-Man: Hobgoblin. Marvel's Ultimate lines basically restart all of their characters in more modern settings. They're aimed largely at teens, but I like them. In this one, they promise Harry Osborne as the Hobgoblin (hence the title; and no, this shouldn't surprise long-time readers, nor anyone who has seen the movies).
- Arrowsmith: So Smart in their Fine Uniforms. I know nothing about this book. No, actually, I know one thing about this book: it's written by Kurt Busiek. For the discriminating comic reader, that's reason enough to shell out $14.95. The premise appears to be World War I mixed with the supernatural.
- We3. I know two things about this book: it's written by Grant Morrison (which means that, like a book by Mr. Busiek, it's almost guaranteed to be good); and the cover has a dog, a cat, and a rabbit in what looks like battle armor. I'm a sucker for animal stories. I suspect it will turn out to be about the eeeevils of animal testing, one of Mr. Morrison's favorite hobby horses (joke unintentional, but irresistable). If so, it will probably take his usual simple-minded "all testing is bad" line; but even when Mr. Morrison is simple-minded, he still writes well.